May 1994

1994 President’s Trophy Air Race

Held at Tempe, Bloemfontein – 26 to 28 May 1994
Pictures and article by John Miller

Cold and windy conditions at Tempe for the 1994 President's Trophy Air Race.
Cold and windy conditions at Tempe for the 1994 President’s Trophy Air Race.

In Cessna’s 1979 model 310R brochure, the blurb at the back quotes a top speed figure of 207 knots at sea level and 195 knots at 75% power at 7500ft. That this year’s handicappers gave 1994 race winners Werner and Johan van Gruting a speed of 188.50 knots should, therefore, come as no surprise. Over the two days of the competition, the Van Gruting brothers managed an actual speed of 201.30 knots and yet competitors were still poking around the 310’s airframe for hidden speed mods. It didn’t help that the only other 3108 in the race, ZS-JOS flew at 193 knots which doesn’t explain anything.

Aero Club of South Africa boss and past race winner, Mike van Ginkel summed it up, “The only entrants ultimately satisfied with the handicappers are the winners”. This year, the competition, sponsored by aviation finance group MLS Bank, produced more than its usual bevy of objections, most of them aimed at the handicappers, which many thought they were running the race against. To make matters worse, weather conditions over the two day event should have favoured the higher powered aircraft – winds on the first day were gusting to 25 and 30 knots at times. Although the first three places were taken by a fast twin and two high performance singles, Free State farmer, Charlie Bosman’s fast B58 Baron was the next twin home at only 12th place. In between were plenty of ‘low powered’ singles. Last year’s winners, Steve Hartley and Joe Grove flying the same Baron B55, ZS-OOG claimed a compass malfunction, which left them well out of the race after the first day and second from last overall. Steve was seen consoling himself on the floor of the Bloemfontein Flying Club bar after the first day’s racing.

Chris Briers puts the wheels away quickly but still battles against the handicappers.
Chris Briers puts the wheels away quickly but still battles against the handicappers.

There were 67 competitors this year and judging by the show of hands at the prize giving ball, 50% were first time entrants. On the first day the fastest aeroplanes launch first at one minute intervals and the order is reversed on day two with separation based on first day results. The competition is essentially won by flying straight, accurately and figuring out the best height under the prevailing winds. Those serious about winning often practice low-level navigation for weeks prior to the contest and the top teams navigators will call out check points some two minutes before they appear along the course, also giving plenty of time to warn the pilot at each turn point – usually over an airfield. Needless to say, GPS is banned. Entrants further prepare by polishing their aircraft and extract maximum performance by flying with the ball in the middle at power settings a thin line from never-exceed limits. Winning can be a matter of seconds, and turbocharged aeroplane pilots have to decide if the extra time climbing to take advantage of their blowers is worth the effort – at around race heights – typically between 5000 and 7000ft, turbo’d engines have the barest advantage which is taken into consideration by the handicappers anyway. Van Ginkel, himself a winner in 1969 and 1972 has won by a nail-biting seven minutes and eleven seconds over a 1000nm course and reckons the first ten crews across the line on the second day will have made virtually no mistakes.

1994 PTAR - van Gruting: van Gruting Brothers - 1994 Winners.
1994 PTAR – van Gruting: van Gruting Brothers – 1994 Winners.
The race has an excellent record of safety, but isn’t always without incident. This year, Carltonville team Bill Stewart and Johann van Rensburg had an engine stoppage and skillfully forced-lobbed onto a dirt road near Ladybrand without damaging their Turbo Arrow lll. Bloemfontein Pilot Jack Onderstall made a successful precautionary landing in a field a few miles short of Tempe after suffering a fuel leak.

It was suggested by one long time pilot that the disatisfaction over handicapping has turned competitors away from the race – something which needs to be addressed. The system appears to be confusing and perhaps needs explaining – the race committee has recorded individual aircraft speeds throughout the past 30 years and many parameters are taken into account including crew experience. The number of entrants has reached 120 in the past and the organisers need to look at their publicity and media efforts to attract greater interest in the event. The air race is an exciting occasion for all participants and hones both flying and navigation skills – the weekend is strong on aviation-talk, the prize giving evening is splendid and the event attracts great support from NAC, the Bloemfontein Flying Club and Midwest Aviation, not to say those most valuable of sponsors – MLS Bank.

 

1994 President’s Trophy Air Race

Held at Tempe, Bloemfontein – 26 to 28 May 1994

Total Distance: 636.12 Nautical Miles

Pos Race
No
A/c Reg Aircraft HP H/Cap
Knots
Gain(-)
Loss
Speed
Knots
Pilot
Navigator
Province
Club
1 51 ZS-KRK Cessna C310 285 188.5 00.12.22- 201.30 Werner van Gruting
Johan van Gruting
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
2 2 ZS-RMA Beech F33 285 165.3 00:10.49- 173.80 John Mayer
Marius Els
Tvl
None
3 4 ZS-JFN Beech A36 285 163.4 00.09.20- 170.54 Tommy Marx
Marion Marx
Free State
Welkom FC
4 32 ZS-IKJ Piper PA28-180 180 123.8 00:08.13- 127.22 André Koen
Neels Erasmus
K Z N
Pongola FC
5 11 ZS-FIE Cessna C172I 150 110.5 00:06.37- 112.78 Essie Esterhuysen
Kobus van der Kolf
Tvl
Aero Club
6 12 ZS-FJV Cessna C172 150 110.5 00.06.36- 112.78 Frikkie Lubbe
Nina Steenkamp
Cape
Upington FC
7 15 ZS-JLD Piper PA28-R200 200 138.5 00.06.27- 141.99 Andries Botha
John McDonald
Free State
Parys FC
8 33 ZS-LOM Cessna C210N 285 162.5 00.06.21- 167.40 Chris Steenkamp
Danie Terblanche
Cape
Upington FC
9 62 ZS-KAL Beech F33A 285 165.3 00:06.18- 170.08 Barry Dix-Peek
Albert Stewardson
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
10 68 ZS-ISW Piper PA28-R200 200 138.5 00.05.56- 141.67 Jeff Shaw
CC Berriman
Tvl
Durban Wings Club
11 16 ZS-LBO Cessna C182RG 235 150.3 00.05.47- 154.02 Peter Bouwer
Chris Booysen
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
12 54 ZS-FBT Beech 58 285 189.3 00:05.36- 195.13 Charles Bosman
Anton van Wyk
Cape
None
13 8 ZS-JOS Cessna C310R 285 188.5 00:04.37- 193.35 Marius Eksteen
Gerhard Hattingh
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
14 43 ZS-LAI Cessna R182RG 235 150.3 00:03.05- 152.18 Rob Dowding
Warren Collier
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
15 22 ZS-MLX Cessna R172K 195 124.8 00:02.59- 126.21 Phillip van Niekerk
Maurice Nathan
Tvl
Aero Club
16 26 ZS-JIG Cessna C182Q 230 135.2 00.02.22- 136.50 Lumon Stadlander
Renette Stadlander
Free State
None
17 20 ZS-KVT Cessna C172RG 180 134.3 00:02.13- 135.63 Ivanhoe Perelson
Dave Perelson
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
18 50 ZS-PIC Beech E55 285 192.1 00:02.06- 194.53 Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer
Alf J Coetzer
Free State
None
19 18 ZS-NHZ Piper PA31-350 350 191.0 00.01.49- 192.76 Michau Huisamen
Peter Meyer
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
20 3 V5-JFP Beech V35B 285 165.3 00:01.28- 166.52 Bennie du Plessis
Jannie Visser
Namibia
None
21 34 ZS-KCD Beech 58 285 189.3 00:01.20- 191.02 Norman Dixie
Geoff Henschel
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
22 14 ZS-DYK Mooney M20C-Mrk21 180 146.5 00:01.16- 147.25 Rodney Redhill
Roland Grinker
Tvl
E A A 322
23 69 ZS-LSZ Cessna C210L 285 163.3 00:00.58- 164.37 Rob Turner
Richard Thornton
N/Tvl
Defence FC
24 9 ZS-LCC Piper PA28-181 180 127.7 00:00.48- 128.25 Hannes Roets
Gerrie van Hiekerk
Tvl
J.L.P.C
25 37 ZS-MLZ Piper PA31-310 310 198.0 00:00.19- 198.79 Chris Briers
Tony Straughan
Tvl
Letaba FC
26 48 ZS-WSE North Am Harvard 550 162.0 00:00.10- 162.27 Chris Kyle
John Sayers
Tvl
None
27 57 ZS-LUH Cessna C210 285 164.3 00:00.02- 164.37 Dave Mandel
Simon Mandel
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
28 19 ZS-MFH Cessna C210M 285 163.3 00:00.16 163.52 Henk Klopper
Kym Morton
Tvl
None
29 59 ZS-CMU Cessna 182C 230 133.3 00:00.59 133.08 Roland van Tonder
Gert Ehlers
Tvl
None
30 29 ZS-DZE Piper PA28-140 150 116.2 00.01.08 115.86 Anthony Fuller
David Forster
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
31 25 ZS-KVN Cessna C210N 285 164.3 00:02.00 163.10 Jabra van Wyk
Newton Walker
Cape
Upington FC
32 44 ZS-IHO Beech B55 260 186.5 00:03.20 183.85 Philip Gidish
Richard Gundersen
Tvl
Brakpan/Benoni
33 27 ZS-KNJ Cessna C182RG 235 150.3 00.03.25 148.62 Charl Starke
Neville Strauss
Cape
None
34 63 ZS-KEM Mooney M2OJ 200 159.6 00.03.26 157.45 Phillip Bierman
Houkie Mostert
Free State
Vanderbijlpark FC
35 56 ZS-MZC Beech F33 285 165.3 00.05.32 165.22 John Legh
Graeme Clarke
Tvl
Aero Club
36 65 ZS-LAD Mooney M2OJ 200 159.6 00:05.56 155.91 Arthur Engelbrecht
Dudley Snell
Tvl
Benoni/Brakpan
37 21 ZS-KLA Beech A36TC 300 181.9 00:06.51 176.21 Nigel Townshend
Steve Dewsbery
Tvl
Aero Club
38 64 ZS-KSF Cessna C172 160 115.3 00:06.51 112.98 Anthony Miller
Dick Stear
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
39 57 ZS-EBJ Piper PA28-140 160 117.2 00:08.22 114.41 Robert Grantham
Juan Venter
Bop
Beuchamp Proctor
40 6 ZS-ECJ Beech V35B 285 165.3 00:09.04 159.43 Anthony Franckel
Ian Solomon
Tvl
None
41 47 ZS-MGS Beech F33 285 165.3 00:10.59 157.84 Neil Hellmmn
Denise Hellmmn
Tvl
None
42 52 ZS-MEA Piper PA28-R201T 200 158.8 00:11.08 151.82 Willie Coetzee
Chris Gerber
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
43 10 ZS-JMW Cessna C177RGII 200 142.7 00:11.09 137.09 Johan Bence
Peter Franks
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
44 58 ZS-EOX Piper PA28-180 180 121.9 00:11.15 117.80 Louis Potgieter
Boet Kleinhans
Free State
Parys FC
45 60 ZS-JIA Piper PA28-180 180 123.8 00:13.23 119.12 Louis Kritzinger
Johan Loubscher
Free State
None
46 12 ZS-FBK Cessna C182 230 135.2 00.14.59 128.51 Willie du Plessis
Deon Matthysen
K Z N
Zululand FC
47 46 ZS-MTO Cessna C210T 285 169.9 00:15.11 159.43 Gerhard Streicher
Cornelius Ferreira
Tvl
Secunda FC
48 10 ZS-CBE Mooney M20C 180 142.7 00.16.37 134.48 Louis Farrell
Carel van Vuuren
Free State
None
49 41 ZS-DOB Beech G35 225 157.8 00:16.42 147.93 Mark Holliday
Robin Holliday
Tvl
Lanseria FC
50 45 ZS-IAM Cessna C182N 230 135.2 00:19.18 126.71 Sarel v d Merwe
Mike Howell
Cape
None
51 53 ZS-ICX Piper PA28-R200 200 137.1 00:21.20 127.48 Peter Minchin
Richard Roberts
Bop
None
52 70 ZS-PFC Cessna C172H 145 108.6 00:23.27 101.94 Jozua Cloete
Dave Naude
Tvl
Defence FC
53 36 ZS-EMU Piper PA28-180Vp 180 124.3 00:27.23 121.39 Robert L Myburgh
Graham Ross
Tvl
Aero Club
54 7 ZS-MDT Cessna C414 310 202.0 00:28.05 176.21 Carl Grobler
Henk Freeke
Tvl
Potchefstroom
55 35 ZS-FHM Mooney M20G 180 144.6 00:30.20 139.19 Pieter Nel
Eben Mocke
Cape
Upington FC
56 38 ZS-FJT Cessna C172 150 110.5 00.33.07 100.97 Dieter Bock
Christo Lombard
Tvl
Krugersdorp FC
57 17 ZS-CHN Mooney Mark20 150 137.1 00.33.57 122.33 Jan Hanekom
Willie Venter
N/Tvl
Defence FC
58 40 ZS-EUM Beech A23-24 200 124.8 00:34.56 112.38 William Mutlow
Marco Fourie
N/Tvl
Defence FC
59 1 ZS-OOG Beech B55 260 186.5 00:54.19 159.83 Steve Hartley
Joe Grove
Tvl
None
60 39 ZS-EXO Piper PA28-140 160 117.2 00:57.16 99.70 Johan Cronje
David Hattingh
Tvl
Defence FC

1994 President’s Trophy Air Race

Tempe – Bloemfontein 26 to 28 May 1994

Trophy Name Awarded to Race A/c Reg Pilot/Navigator
Aircraft
President’s Trophy The Competitor gaining most time on Handicap 51 ZS-KRK Werner van Gruting/Johan van Gruting
Cessna C310
Air Charter Trophy The Second Pilot Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Maruis Els
Beech F33
Vincent Maclean Trophy The Third Pilot Home 4 ZS-JFN Tommy Marx/Marion Marx
Beech A36
Natal Mercury Trophy The First Kwa Zulu Natal Pilot Home 32 ZS-IKJ André Koen/Neels Erasmus
Piper PA28-180
Hoofstad Pers Trophy The First Transvaal Pilot Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Maruis Els
Beech F33
Stellalander Trophy The First Cape Pilot Home 12 ZS-FJV Frikkie Lubbe/Nina Steenkamp
Cessna C172
Phoenix Volkswagen Trophy The First Free State Pilot Home 51 ZS-KRK Werner van Gruting/Johan van Gruting
Cessna C310
Northern Review Trophy The First Northern Transvaal Pilot Home 69 ZS-MLZ Chris Briers/Tony Straughan
Piper PA31-310
Springall Trophy The First Bophuthatswana Pilot Home 67 ZS-EBJ Robert Grantham/Juan Venter
Piper PA28-140
Gatsby Trophy Best Handicap Performance on First Day 51 ZS-KRK Werner van Gruting/Johan van Gruting
Cessna C310
Wakefield Trophy The First Woman Pilot Home 20 ZS-KVT Ivanhoe Perelson/Dave Perelson
Cessna C172RG
Kassie Kasselman Trophy The First Father and Son Combination Home 50 ZS-PTC Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer/Alf J Coetzer
Beech E55
John Sayers Trophy The Crew of The First Turbocharged Aircraft Home 18 ZS-NHZ Michau Huisamen/Peter Meyer
Piper PA31-350
Bloemfontein Flying Club Trophy The First Team with less than 1000 Hours 32 ZS-IKJ André Koen/Neels Erasmus
Piper PA28-180
C A A Trophy For Professionalism 48 ZS-WSE Chris Kyle/John Sayers
North Am Harvard
Beechcraft Trophy The Pilot of the First Beechcraft Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Maruis Els
Beech F33
Comair Trophy The Pilot of the First Cessna Home 51 ZS-KRK Werner van Gruting/Johan van Gruting
Cessna C310
Southern Africa Mooney Trophy The Pilot of the First Mooney Home 14 ZS-DYK Rodney Redhill/Roland Grinker
Mooney M20C-Mrk21
Placo Trophy The Pilot of the First Piper Home 32 ZS-IKJ André Koen/Neels Erasmus
Piper PA28-180
Natal Advertiser Trophy The Competitor covering the course in the Fastest Time 51 ZS-KRK Werner van Gruting/Johan van Gruting
Cessna C310
Badian Bosch Memorial Trophy The First Port Elizabeth Pilot Home 62 ZS-KAL Barry Dix-Peek/Albert Stewardson
Beech F33A
Durban Wings Club Trophy The Pilot of the First Durban Wings Club Pilot Home 68 ZS-ISW Jeff Shaw/CC Berriman
Piper PA28-R200
Chris Swart Krugersdorp Trophy The First Krugersdorp Pilot Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Marius Els
Beech F33
J L P C Trophy The First Johannesburg Light Plane Club Pilot Home 9 ZS-LCC Hannes Roets/Gerrie van Niekerk
Piper PA28-181
Professional Aviation Trophy The First Turbine Rated Pilot/Navigator Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Marius Els
Beech F33
Carletonville Trophy The Pilot of the First Baron Home 54 ZS-FBT Charles Bosman/Anton van Wyk
Beech 58
Preller/Germishuys Trophy Handicapping Committee Award 28 ZS-KBM W Stewart/F van Rensburg
Piper PA28-R200

Race
No
A/c Reg Pilot
Navigator
Aircraft Reason for exclusion
4 ZS-KOV Stuart Connacher
Rob Connacher
Cessna C182 Missed all turning points Day 1
23 ZS-FLR Ron Pollock
Grant Emary
Beech V35A Returned early after getting lost
24 ZS-PAP Frans Rossouw
Roelof McDonald
Piper PA28-140 Missed all turning points Day 1
28 ZS-KBM W Stewart
F van Resnburh
Piper PA28-R200 Forced landing near Ficksburg Day 1
31 ZS-NGN Carlo Talevi
Cilliers Manser
Cessna 170A Did not start Day 2
55 ZS-EHG Jack Onderstall
Lynette Jeppe
Cessna C172 Forced landing on way to Tempe Day 1

 

Penalties

Race No A/c Reg Penalty Reason
1 ZS-OOG 00:20:00 Missed turning point Ficksburg
35 ZS-FHM 00:20:00 Missed turning point Ficksburg
36 ZS-EMU 00:20:00 Not seen at Philippolis
40 ZS-EUM 00:01:00 Turned short Bethulie
56 ZS-MZC 00:05:00 Wrong direction Ficksburg
60 ZS-JIA 00:01:00 Turned short Bethulie

1994 PTAR – Picture gallery