May 1995

1995 President’s Trophy Air Race

Held at Port Alfred – 11 to 13 May 1995

Pictures and article by John Miller

1995 PTAR - Aero Africa: Pictures by John Miller appeared in Aero Africa
1995 PTAR – Aero Africa: Pictures by John Miller appeared in Aero Africa

44 year old consulting engineer, Nigel Townshend, leans forward slightly as his immaculate Bonanza A36TC charges down Port Alfred’s grass runway 10, leaving a swirling cloud of disturbed grass cuttings behind. No longer than seconds after lifting clear, he reaches under the throw-over control column and flicks the gear lever to up. Staying low, rushing towards the marshal with his clipboard poised at the end of the strip, the leather-chaired turbo Bonanza accelerates hard towards its maximum speed. The throttle and propeller plungers are firewalled. Seconds later, the whiteshirted man with the clipboard blurs past and Townshend throws the A36 into a military wings-vertical left turn towards the north and snaps the wings back again, staying close to the trees, bushes and telephone wires passing beneath at close to 170 knots increasing.
In the right seat, navigator Rod Hering spreads his own clipboard,armed with two digital stopwatches, and quickly moves his head between a quarter million area chart to the the skyline. There is a moment’s silence between the heading instructions as the whitewashed Pig and Whistle Inn at Bathurst flashes past the left wingtip. Neither Townshend or Hering can see far at this height – the horizon disappears at the next ridge two kilometers away and the map, almost useless to a normal Bonanza trip, becomes everything to pilots and navigators competing in the Presidents Air Race.

1995 President's Trophy Air Race Winners - Howell and van der Merwe
1995 President’s Trophy Air Race Winners – Howell and van der Merwe

The race is an exercise in precise navigation and for once flying skill is of secondary importance, but it helps. The first day takes competitors to Somerset East and Jansenville before returning to Port Alfred. The course on the second day takes the 49 crews 250 miles north across the Eastern Cape scrub to the first turn at Cradock, then east to Queenstown and south to the finish line at Port Alfred. A mere half mile off track is enough to put a competitor out of the running unless the handicap is favorable. There’s high ground between Port Alfred and Cradock, either forcing a climb from sea level to 4500ft or a mile detour along the north- stretching valley.

1995’s winners, Mike Howell and Sarel van der Merwe in their normally aspirated Beech A36, chose to take the extra mile rather than make the climb – it paid off, helped by a handicap speed 5 knots less than their maximum. For the first time in six years, the Presidents Air Race had been brought to the coast and away from its traditional home at Tempe airfield in Bloemfontein. The new venue promised, amongst other things, less predictable weather and a little advantage for turbocharged aircraft.

John Leigh and Graeme Clark launch for the second day's race
John Leigh and Graeme Clark launch for the second day’s race
By the time all competitors had arrived at Port Alfred, the organisers had 50 aeroplanes lined up on the newly mowed grass adjacent to Jim Davis’ 43 Air School premises. Furthermore, the weathermen were predicting near-perfect conditions – CAVOK and little wind for the weekend, giving lower-powered aircraft a chance to match the handicappers and take home some trophies.

Many entrants called the handicapping unfair.
Many entrants called the handicapping unfair.

The air race organisers have been struggling to maintain numbers for the once popular event and 1995 saw a further decline in entrants, which only a few years ago attracted over 150 aeroplanes. As usual the keen competitors, many of whom appear year after year, voiced strong concern over handicapping. It’s generally accepted that aircraft of identical model and year manufacture can have different maximum cruise speeds of up to five knots. Competitors are dissatisfied with handicap speeds that bear little resemblance to published figures, and in cases disagree with the committee’s policy of basing speeds on past race histories. There’s no doubt that the existing system leaves a great deal to be desired and it’s discouraging entries. Moves are afoot to change next year’s handicapping criteria in an effort to boost entries.

Nevertheless, many top competitors spent time before the event practicing their low-level navigation. Although the winners, Howell and Van der Merwe from Hotazel didn’t practice, they came right with the handicappers and navigation. It was their sixth race and their Bonanza completed the course at 171.95 knots – 5.75 knots above handicap speed. Those serious about winning will know how best to fly their aircraft. Light crisp turns at the check points are quicker than long broad sweeps. A Baron flown with the correct technique can gain as much as ten seconds on a turn which can save 60 seconds over the entire event or three miles – a valuable advantage. Some competitors go as far as switching off unnecessary electricals – hoping that by unloading the alternator, the engine has more power to the crank.

Flying technique did little for Townshend and Hering. The Johannesburg team became confused with the topographical information halfway to Cradock. The two pulled up and unable to recognise Bedford, turned hard left in an attempt to reestablish the track and were almost immediately out of the running after a good first day.

The 1995 event was sponsored by aircraft financing group MLS Bank. As usual NAC were there in force, as were others to help with organisation and time-keeping. Kassie Kaseleman from Bloemfontein, long time organiser, had arranged another successful event.

Port Alfred
FZI taking off

1995 President’s Trophy Air Race

Held at Port Alfred – 11 to 13 May 1995

Total Distance: 598.40 Nautical Miles

Pos Race
No
A/c Reg Aircraft HP H/Cap
Knots
Gain(-)
Loss
Speed
Knots
Pilot
Navigator
Province
Club
1 45 ZS-KJI Beech A36 285 166.2 00:07.05- 171.95 Mike Howell
Sarel van der Merwe
Cape
None
2 33 ZS-LOM Cessna C210N Stol 300 164.3 00:05.01- 168.56 Chris Steenkamp
Danie Terreblanche
Cape
Upington FC
3 8 ZS-JKA Beech A36 285 166.2 00:04.04- 169.52 Sias Delport
Frikkie van Zyl
Cape
Vaalharts FC
4 2 ZS-RMA Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:03.25- 173.95 John Mayer
Peter Walker
Tvl
Krugersdorp FC
5 4 ZS-JFN Beech A36 285 166.2 00:03.07- 169.04 Tommy Marx
Marion Marx
Free State
Welkom FC
6 3 ZS-KMV Beech V35B 285 170.8 00:01.51- 172.45 Jannie Visser
Josephine Kruger
Cape
Kuruman FC
7 14 ZS-FWB Beech D55 285 194.9 00:01.27- 196.84 Anthony Frankel
Chris Chapman
Tvl
None
8 43 ZS-LBO Cessna C182RG 235 152.1 00:00.41- 152.65 Warren Collier
Rob Dowding
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
9 31 ZS-NGN Cessna 170Vp 180 124.8 00:00.32- 125.18 Carlo Talevi
Cilliers Manser
Tvl
Krugersdorp FC
10 23 ZS-FLR Beech V35A 285 170.8 00:00.30- 171.46 Ron Pollock
Ed Emary
Tvl
B.B.A.C.
11 12 ZS-FJV Cessna C172 150 116.2 00:00.17- 116.42 Nina Steenkamp
Frikkie Lubbe
Cape
Upington FC
12 22 ZS-KOK Cessna 182Q 230 139.9 00:00.15 139.81 Phillip van Niekerk
Maurice Nathan
Tvl
Aero Club
13 50 ZS-PTC Beech E55 (2-Bl) 285 197.3 00:00.17 197.49 Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer
Alf J Coetzer
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
14 44 ZS-IHO Beech B55 260 187.5 00:00.23 187.58 Philip Gidish
Richard Gundersen
Tvl
East Rand FC
15 47 ZS-MGS Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:01.13 170.00 Neil Hellmann
Denise Hellmann
Tvl
None
16 11 ZS-LJG Cessna C170B 145 113.4 00:02.11 112.69 Johan Dorfling
Herman Kemp
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
17 49 ZS-DZZ Piper PA24-400 400 192.0 00:02.23 189.97 John Sayers
Chris Kyle
Tvl
Durban Wings Club
18 19 ZS-MFH Cessna C210M 285 166.2 00:02.48 164.39 Henk Klopper
Kim Morton
Tvl
None
19 34 ZS-FLV Beech A36 285 166.2 00:02.54 164.39 Norman Dixie
Geoff Henschel
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
20 28 ZS-FZY Siai M. SF260 260 175.4 00:03.06 172.95 Vernon Brito
Albert Stewardson
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
21 30 ZS-KOW Cessna 182Q 230 139.9 00:03.11 138.20 Dirk van Reenen
Edwin Spence
Free State
None
22 24 ZS-JOS Cessna C31OR 285 192.3 00:03.26 189.37 Marius Eksteen
Johan Laubscher
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
23 32 ZS-ETX Cessna C210 300 166.2 00:04.28 163.05 Rob Turner
Johan Ehmke
N/Tvl
Defence FC
24 9 ZS-NAD Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:04.49 167.15 Faan van Tonder
Hannes Roets
Tvl
J.L.P.C
25 48 ZS-LAI Cessna C182RG 235 152.1 00:04.55 149.22 Anthony Miller
Dick Stear
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
26 56 ZS-MZC Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:05.01 170.00 John Legh
Graeme Clarke
Tvl
Aero Club
27 35 ZS-NFJ Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:07.28 165.30 Rob Turner
P J P van Blerk
Tvl
Lanseria FC
28 39 ZS-KHE Beech F33A 285 170.8 00:07.50 164.85 Anthony Perl
David Rosmarin
Tvl
None
29 41 ZS-KSF Cessna C172 160 120.0 00:08.51 116.64 Peter van Der Poel
David Louw
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
30 15 ZS-JLD Piper PA28-R200 200 143.7 00:08.52 138.84 Andries Botha
John McDonald
Free State
Parys FC
31 10 ZS-LPY Cessna U206C 300 141.8 00:11.02 138.20 Dave Forster
Tony Fuller
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
32 17 ZS-JGJ Piper PA28-151 150 119.1 00:11.15 114.85 Pieter Kolver
Nico Vermeulen
Free State
Bloemfontein FC
33 20 N9170N Mooney M20R 280 193.0 00:11.56 181.88 Patrick Hanly
James Paizes
Cape
None
34 5 ZS-KOV Cessna C182Q 230 137.9 00:12.23 131.80 Stuart Connacher
Rob Connacher
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
35 36 ZS-EMU Piper PA28-180Vp 180 129.1 00:13.44 123.12 Robert L Myburgh
Robert C Myburgh
Tvl
Aero Club
36 59 ZS-DRK Cessna 182G 230 139.9 00:14.22 132.68 P J Bezuidenhout
J van Zyl
N/Tvl
Krugersdorp FC
37 25 ZS-LWP Mooney 205SE 200 168.5 00:15.32 157.06 B Schabort
C G Joseph
Tvl
None
38 58 ZS-EOX Piper PA28-180 180 127.7 00:15.41 121.13 Louis Potgieter
Boet Kleinhans
Free State
Parys FC
39 27 ZS-HCC Piper PA28-R200 200 143.7 00:16.09 135.08 P C Viviers
Hans Botha
Tvl
None
40 26 ZS-KCY Cessna 177RG 200 147.4 00:16.35 138.20 Rex Mcgregor
Margo Mcgregor
Cape
Algoa Flying Club
41 7 ZS-MDT Cessna C414 310 199.0 00:16.38 182.44 Carl Grobler
Henk Freeke
Tvl
Potch FC
42 37 ZS-DZL Cessna C320 260 195.8 00:16.50 179.70 Jan Vorster
Peter McKellor
N/Tvl
None
43 40 ZS-LPW Piper PA28-180R 180 140.4 00:17.01 131.80 Clive Kewley
Jonathan du Rand
K Z N
Durban Wings Club
44 38 ZS-FJT Cessna C172K 150 116.2 00:17.17 110.20 Dieter Bock
Renier Moolman
Tvl
Krugersoorp FC
45 52 ZS-MIF Piper PA32-R301T 300 180.1 00:20.58 163.05 J Pienaar
Jaques Griessel
Free State
None
46 51 ZS-ESZ Piper PA28-180Vp 180 129.1 00.24.42 118.73 Gert Ehlers
Roland van Tonder
N/Tvl
None
47 21 ZS-KLA Beech BE36TC 300 188.5 00:30.59 162.17 Nigel Townshend
Rod Hering
Tvl
Aero Club
48 60 ZS-KYK Cessna C172RG 180 139.0 00:34.51 122.62 J Cloete
T A Whiting
N/Tvl
Defence FC
49 57 N388CA Rockwell 114 260 158.3 00:36.41 136.31 Ken Heuer
Andrew Currin
Tvl
None
50 42 ZS-FBK Cessna C182K 230 139.9 00:45.41 118.96 Willie Du Plessis
Deon Matthysen
K Z N
Zululand FC

1995 President’s Trophy Air Race

Port Alfred 11 to 13 May 1995

Trophy Name Awarded to Race A/c Reg Pilot/Navigator
Aircraft
President’s Trophy The Competitor gaining most time on Handicap 45 ZS-KJI Mike Howell/Sarel van der Merwe
Beech A36
Air Charter Trophy The Second Pilot Home 33 ZS-LOM Chris Steenkamp/Danie Terreblanche
Cessna C210 STOL
Vincent Maclean Trophy The Third Pilot Home 8 ZS-JKA Sias Delport/Frikkie van Zyl
Beech A36
Natal Mercury Trophy The First Kwa Zulu Natal Pilot Home 40 ZS-LPW Clive Kewley/Jonathan du Rand
Piper PA28-180R
Hoofstad Pers Trophy The First Transvaal Pilot Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Peter Walker
Beech F33A
Stellalander Trophy The First Cape Pilot Home 45 ZS-KJI Mike Howell/Sarel van der Merwe
Beech A36
Phoenix Volkswagen Trophy The First Free State Pilot Home 4 ZS-JFN Tommy Marx/Marion Marx
Beech A36
Northern Review Trophy The First Northern Transvaal Pilot Home 32 ZS-ETX Rob Turner/Johan Ehmke
Cessna C210
Gatsby Trophy Best Handicap Performance on First Day 45 ZS-KJI Mike Howell/Sarel van der Merwe
Beech A36
Wakefield Trophy The First Woman Pilot Home 12 ZS-FJV Nina Steenkamp/Frikkie Lubbe
Cessna C172
Kassie Kasselman Trophy The First Father and Son Combination Home 50 ZS-PTC Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer/Alf J Coetzer
Beech E55
John Sayers Trophy The Crew of The First Turbocharged Aircraft Home 7 ZS-MDT Carel Grobler/Henk Freeke
Cessna C414
Bloemfontein Flying Club Trophy The First Team with less than 1000 Hours 43 ZS-LBO Warren Collier/Rob Dowding
Cessna C182RG
C A A Trophy For Professionalism 24 ZS-JOS Maruis Eksteen/Johan Laubscher
Cessna C310R
Beechcraft Trophy The Pilot of the First Beechcraft Home 45 ZS-KJI Mike Howell/Sarel van der Merwe
Beech A36
Comair Trophy The Pilot of the First Cessna Home 33 ZS-LOM Chris Steenkamp/Danie Terreblanche
Cessna C210 STOL
Placo Trophy The Pilot of the First Piper Home 49 ZS-DZZ John Sayers/Chris Kyle
Piper PA24-400
Vickers Trophy The Competitor Giving The Most Meritorious Performance 23 ZS-FLR Ron Pollock/Ed Emary
Beech V35A
Stayers Trophy The Crew Finishing under Exceptional Circumstances 19 ZS-MFH Henk Klopper/Kim Morton
Cessna C210M
Natal Advertiser Trophy The Competitor covering the course in the Fastest Time 50 ZS-PTC Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer/Alf J Coetzer
Beech E55
Badian Bosch Memorial Trophy The First Port Elizabeth Pilot Home 43 ZS-LBO Warren Collier/Rob Dowding
Cessna C182RG
Durban Wings Club Trophy The Pilot of the First Durban Wings Club Pilot Home 49 ZS-DZZ John Sayers/Chris Kyle
Piper PA24-400
Chris Swart Krugersdorp Trophy The First Krugersdorp Pilot Home 2 ZS-RMA John Mayer/Peter Walker
Beech F33A
J L P C Trophy The First Johannesburg Light Plane Club Pilot Home 9 ZS-NAD Faan van Tonder/Hannes Roets
Beech F33A
Professional Aviation Trophy The First Turbine Rated Pilot/Navigator Home 33 ZS-LOM Chris Steenkamp/Danie Terreblanche
Cessna C210 STOL
Carletonville Trophy The Pilot of the First Baron Home 14 ZS-FWB Anthony Frankel/Chris Chapman
Beech D55
Preller/Germishuys Trophy Handicapping Committee Award 50 ZS-PTC Jacobus (Koos) Coetzer/Alf J Coetzer
Beech E55

Penalties

Race No A/c Reg Penalty Reason
10 ZS-LPY 00:04:00 Not seen at Queenstown
56 ZS-MZC 00:04:00 Not seen at Cathcart